Good Will × Good Coffee

PENN YAN • FINGER LAKES NEW YORK

Amity Coffee Co. is more than just a coffee shop—it’s a gathering place, a morning ritual, and a space where friendships take root. Inspired by the very meaning of its name, Amity was built on the belief that coffee is best enjoyed in good company, with conversation flowing as freely as the lake’s waves.

Shop Our Coffees

Visit Us

3 Main Street
Penn Yan, New York 14527

Mon–Sat 7a–4p
kitchen closes at 2p daily

Sun 7a-1p

MENU

Our Story

Amity has been serving the community since Because we believe in doing the best for our neighbors, we prioritize roasting our own coffee beans, baking in-house, and sourcing local whenever possible. Whether sipping a cup along the lake or stopping in for fresh pastries, we hope you pause to enjoy the moment.

ABOUT US